Pick up the correct statement(s) about concrete mixing practices:
Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.
Correct answer: D. All options are correct
Detailed Explanation: All Three Concrete Mixing Practices Are Correct
Why D (All options correct) is correct: Each statement reflects an established good practice for machine mixing of concrete.Verification of Each Statement
| Statement | Verdict | Technical Reason |
|---|---|---|
| A. No cement loss from charged drum | Correct | Cement is the most expensive and critical ingredient; any loss changes the w/c ratio and reduces strength. The drum should be properly charged and sealed during mixing |
| B. Mix for at least 1 minute | Correct | IS 1791 specifies minimum 2 minutes for batch mixers (some sources cite 1.5 min); 1 minute is the practical minimum to achieve homogeneity. Under-mixing leaves unmixed pockets of dry cement |
| C. 10% water first in drum | Correct | Adding a portion of water to the empty drum before dry materials prevents cement from sticking to drum blades and ensures aggregates are wetted progressively during mixing |
Correct Machine Mixing Procedure
| Step | Action |
|---|---|
| 1 | Start drum rotating |
| 2 | Add ~10% of water to wet the drum |
| 3 | Add coarse aggregate with remaining water |
| 4 | Add cement and fine aggregate |
| 5 | Mix for minimum 1.5–2 minutes (IS 1791) |
| 6 | Discharge completely; check drum for residue |
- All three statements are correct — no cement loss, 1+ minute mixing, and 10% water first.
- IS 1791 specifies minimum mixing time for batch mixers: 2 minutes after all ingredients are in the drum.
- Over-mixing (>3 minutes) can cause aggregate breakdown and heat generation — also undesirable.