Calculate the apex distance, if the deflection angle is 60 degrees and the degree of curve is 8 degrees.
Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.
Detailed Explanation: Apex Distance (External Distance) of a Circular Curve
The apex distance (also called the external distance, E) is the distance from the point of intersection (apex, where the two straight tangents would meet) to the midpoint of the curve. This is a two-step problem: first convert degree of curve to radius, then apply the apex distance formula.
Fig: The apex distance E runs from the apex (point of intersection of the tangents) to the curve's midpoint.
Step-by-step solution:Step 1 — Convert degree of curve to radius (assuming standard 30 m chord convention):
R = 1720 / D = 1720 / 8 = 215 m
Step 2 — Apply the apex distance (external distance) formula:
E = R [sec(Δ/2) − 1]
E = 215 × [sec(30°) − 1] = 215 × [1.1547 − 1] = 215 × 0.1547 = 33.26 m
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
B — 124.13: This does not match the correct apex distance formula result; possibly results from using the wrong trigonometric function or an incorrect value of Δ/2.
C — 215: This is simply the computed radius R itself, not the final apex distance — a common error is stopping the calculation after Step 1 without completing Step 2.
D — 262.8: Overstates the apex distance significantly; likely from an incorrect application of the secant formula or a units/angle error.
Key Concepts for Students
- Apex distance formula uses secant, not cosine: E = R[sec(Δ/2)−1], distinct from the versed sine formula M = R[1−cos(Δ/2)] (Q1) — both involve Δ/2 but use reciprocal trigonometric functions and are measured from different reference points (apex vs. long chord midpoint).
- Multi-step problems often hide a unit-conversion step first: Whenever degree of curve is given instead of radius directly, always convert to R first using the appropriate chord-length constant (Q11, Q15, Q18) before applying any further curve-element formula.
- sec(θ) = 1/cos(θ): If your calculator lacks a direct secant function, compute cos(30°) = 0.866 first, then take the reciprocal (1/0.866 = 1.1547) to get sec(30°) — a useful workaround for this very common curve-formula trigonometric function.