Surveying·MCQ explained

The length of the horizontal transition curve based on the allowable rate change of centrifugal acceleration is 48 m, and based on the rate of introduction of super-elevation is 40 m, and based on the empirical formula recommended by IRC is 45 m. What will be the shift in the transition curve? Take the radius of the curve as 200 m.

Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.

Correct answer: B. 0.48 m

Detailed Explanation: Selecting the Design Length Before Computing Shift

This question tests two things in sequence: first, the design rule for choosing among multiple candidate transition curve lengths, and second, the correct application of the shift formula using that chosen length.

Step-by-step solution:
Step 1 — Select the design length L:
When a transition curve length is computed by multiple independent criteria (centrifugal acceleration, super-elevation introduction rate, IRC empirical formula), standard design practice adopts the maximum of the candidate values, ensuring all individual safety/comfort criteria are simultaneously satisfied. Here: max(48, 40, 45) = 48 m

Step 2 — Apply the shift formula:
S = L² / (24R)
S = 48² / (24 × 200) = 2304 / 4800 = 0.48 m

Why the Other Options Are Wrong

A — 0.42 m: This would result from using L = 45 m (the IRC empirical value) instead of the correct governing maximum value of 48 m.

C — 0.33 m: This would result from using L = 40 m (the super-elevation-based value), again not the governing maximum length.

D — 3.68 m: This is far too large for these inputs and likely results from a significant calculation error, such as omitting the division by 24 or by R² instead of R.

Key Concepts for Students

  • Always take the maximum of multiple candidate transition lengths: This design rule ensures the chosen length is long enough to satisfy every individual safety and comfort criterion simultaneously — a shorter length would violate at least one of the governing conditions.
  • Shift formula: S = L²/(24R): This same formula appears identically in Q14 as a standalone formula question — recognising it here in an applied numerical context reinforces the underlying relationship between transition curve length, circular curve radius, and the resulting shift.
  • Why a "shift" exists at all: Introducing a transition curve between the straight and the circular arc requires the circular curve to be shifted slightly inward (by S) from its original position, so that the transition curve can smoothly connect the straight tangent to the (now-shifted) circular arc without any sudden change in curvature.