Surveying·MCQ explained

In theodolite, what will happen with respect to rotation of upper and lower plates, if the lower clamp is clamped and the upper clamp is unclamped?

Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.

Correct answer: A. Upper plate rotates on inner axis with relative motion between upper and lower plates

Detailed Explanation: The Double-Axis (Upper/Lower Clamp) System

A vernier transit theodolite has two concentric vertical axes — an outer (lower) spindle and an inner (upper) spindle — each with its own clamp. Understanding which clamp controls which axis is essential for correctly using both the "upper motion" and "lower motion" of the instrument.

Why the upper plate rotates on the inner axis here:
The lower plate (the main graduated horizontal circle) is mounted on the outer spindle, and the upper plate (carrying the vernier and the telescope assembly) is mounted on the inner spindle, which sits concentrically inside the outer spindle. When the lower clamp is tightened, the outer spindle (and lower plate) is locked in place. When the upper clamp is simultaneously loosened, the inner spindle is free to rotate — so the upper plate (with the telescope) swings independently relative to the now-fixed lower plate. This creates relative motion between the upper and lower plates, with the upper plate rotating on the inner axis.

Why the Other Options Are Wrong

B — Both plates rotate together: This describes the opposite configuration — both clamps tightened simultaneously is not possible to rotate at all, and "both rotate together" actually describes what happens when the lower clamp is loose and the upper clamp is tight (the whole assembly, both plates, rotates together on the outer axis).

C — Lower plate rotates on outer axis: This reverses the actual mechanism for this specific clamp configuration. With the lower clamp tightened, the lower plate (and outer axis) is locked, not rotating.

D — No motion between plates: If there were no relative motion at all, the horizontal angle reading at the vernier could never change — defeating the entire purpose of unclamping the upper clamp.

Key Concepts for Students

  • Lower clamp tight + upper clamp loose = "upper motion": This is the standard configuration for measuring a horizontal angle between two points from a fixed reference, since the lower plate (graduated circle) stays fixed while the vernier/telescope on the upper plate sweeps to the new target.
  • Upper clamp tight + lower clamp loose = "lower motion": Used for re-orienting the entire instrument (both plates rotate together) without disturbing the horizontal angle already set between the upper vernier and lower circle — useful when repeating angles by the method of repetition.
  • Why this matters for the method of repetition: Surveyors deliberately alternate which clamp is loosened across repeated angle observations to average out instrumental graduation errors — a technique that depends entirely on correctly understanding which plate moves with which clamp.