Surveying·MCQ explained

According to which method of balancing the traverse, is 'the total error in latitudes and in departure distributed in proportion to the latitudes and departure of the sides'?

Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.

Correct answer: C. Transit method

Detailed Explanation: The Transit Rule for Traverse Balancing

Every closed traverse accumulates small angular and linear measurement errors that prevent it from closing exactly. Several rules exist for distributing this closing error among the traverse legs, and choosing the correct rule depends on the relative precision of angle versus distance measurement.

Why this describes the Transit method:
The Transit Rule distributes the total closing error in latitude and departure to each survey line in proportion to the latitude and departure of that line itself (not its length). Correction to latitude of a line = (total latitude error) × (latitude of that line) / (arithmetic sum of all latitudes), and similarly for departure. This rule is applied when angular measurements are considered more precise/reliable than the linear (distance) measurements, since it weights the correction by the line's own latitude/departure component rather than by overall line length.

Comparison of Traverse Balancing Rules

RuleCorrection basisUsed when
Transit ruleProportional to the line's own latitude/departureAngular measurements more precise than linear measurements
Bowditch (compass) ruleProportional to the line's length relative to total perimeterAngular and linear measurements equally precise
Graphical (Axis) methodVisual/graphical adjustment of the plotted traverseQuick approximate corrections, often for rough or preliminary work

Why the Other Options Are Wrong

A — Graphical method: This is a visual, drawing-based correction technique, not a proportional-distribution rule based on latitude/departure ratios.

B — The axis method: This is essentially a variant of the graphical correction approach and does not use the latitude/departure proportional-distribution principle described in the question.

D — Bowditch's method: Bowditch's (compass) rule distributes the error in proportion to the length of each line relative to the total traverse perimeter — not in proportion to each line's own latitude and departure values, which is the specific distinguishing feature of the Transit rule.

Key Concepts for Students

  • Transit rule vs. Bowditch rule — the key distinguishing phrase: If a question says corrections are proportional to a line's "latitude and departure," it is the Transit rule. If it says proportional to "length of the line," it is Bowditch's (compass) rule. This single phrase is the fastest way to distinguish the two on an exam.
  • Why angular precision changes the choice of rule: When angles are measured very precisely (e.g., with a precision theodolite) but distances less so, errors tend to concentrate in the linear components — the Transit rule's latitude/departure-based weighting better reflects this error distribution than a simple length-based rule.
  • Both rules require the algebraic sum of corrected latitudes and departures to equal zero: This is the fundamental closure condition both methods aim to satisfy — they differ only in how the correction is apportioned among the individual lines.