Which type of error is represented by a closed traverse, if the algebraic sum of latitude of all the lines is zero?
Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.
Detailed Explanation: The Latitude Closure Condition for a Closed Traverse
A closed traverse is one that returns to its starting point (or to a point of known coordinates), and its mathematical closure condition provides a direct check on the quality of the field measurements.
Why a zero algebraic sum of latitudes indicates no error (in that component):For a perfectly closed traverse, the sum of all northward latitudes must exactly equal the sum of all southward latitudes — meaning the algebraic sum (north positive, south negative) of all latitudes equals exactly zero. This makes geometric sense: if you walk out from a point and eventually return to that same point, your net north-south displacement must be zero. When this condition holds exactly, there is no error of closure in the north-south (latitude) component of the traverse.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
A — Compensating error: A compensating error is a type of random error that partially cancels out over many measurements but does not necessarily result in an exact zero sum — it describes the nature of certain measurement errors, not the specific zero-closure condition itself.
B — Negative error: If the sum of latitudes were some negative non-zero value, that actually would indicate a closing error (an excess of southward over northward latitudes) — but the question specifies the sum is exactly zero, which is the absence of error, not a negative one.
D — Positive error: Similarly, a positive non-zero sum would indicate a closing error in the north direction — again the opposite of what a zero sum represents.
Key Concepts for Students
- Two independent closure checks for a closed traverse: Algebraic sum of latitudes = 0 (no north-south closing error) AND algebraic sum of departures = 0 (no east-west closing error). Both must hold simultaneously for a perfectly closed traverse with literally zero closing error.
- In practice, a small non-zero sum is expected and corrected: Real field measurements almost always leave a small non-zero closing error in both latitude and departure sums — this is exactly what the Bowditch and Transit balancing rules (Q13, Q22) are designed to distribute and correct.
- This sets up the bearing/quadrant calculations in Q27 and Q43: When the sums are NOT zero, the residual (non-zero) sums of latitude and departure define the closing error vector, whose magnitude and bearing/quadrant are computed exactly as shown in those later questions.