If the sum of northings of a traverse exceeds the sum of southings by 1 m and sum of eastings exceeds the sum of westings by 1 m, the resultant closing error and its true bearing are respectively:
Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.
Detailed Explanation: Computing the Closing Error Magnitude and Bearing
This problem combines the magnitude calculation (Pythagorean theorem, as in Q19) with the quadrant/bearing determination (as in Q27) to fully describe a traverse's closing error vector.
Step-by-step solution:Excess of northing over southing = +1 m (net latitude error is positive, i.e., North)
Excess of easting over westing = +1 m (net departure error is positive, i.e., East)
Magnitude (closing error):
Closing error = √(latitude error² + departure error²) = √(1² + 1²) = √2 = 1.414 m
Bearing:
Since both latitude and departure errors are positive, the closing line lies in the NE quadrant (matching Q27's quadrant table). The bearing angle = tan⁻¹(departure/latitude) = tan⁻¹(1/1) = 45°.
So the true bearing is N 45° E.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
B — 1 m, N 45 E: The bearing N 45° E is correct, but the magnitude is wrong — simply taking one of the two equal component values (1 m) instead of correctly combining both via the Pythagorean theorem understates the true resultant closing error.
C — 2 m, N 45 W: Both the magnitude (incorrectly summing 1+1=2 instead of combining via Pythagoras) and the quadrant (W instead of E, which would require a negative, not positive, departure error) are wrong.
D — 2 m, N 45 E: The bearing is correct, but the magnitude again incorrectly sums the two components directly (1+1=2) instead of applying the Pythagorean relationship, which gives √2 ≈ 1.414 m, not 2 m.
Key Concepts for Students
- Never simply add or average latitude and departure errors for magnitude: As emphasised in Q19, latitude and departure are perpendicular vector components; combining them for a resultant magnitude always requires the Pythagorean theorem, never direct addition.
- Equal latitude and departure errors always give a 45° bearing: Whenever the magnitudes of the latitude and departure errors are equal, tan⁻¹(1) = 45° exactly — a useful shortcut to recognise immediately in such symmetric problems.
- Combine quadrant logic (Q27) with magnitude logic (Q19) for full closing-error description: A complete closing-error answer always needs both pieces — the numeric distance (magnitude) and the directional quadrant-based bearing — together fully describing the closing-error vector.