An airport runway fill needs 8,50,000 m³ of soil compacted to void ratio of 0.7. The required soil is to be taken from a borrow pit having an in situ void ratio of 0.8. If the transportation cost is ₹10 per m³, estimated cost for the filling work is (in ₹):
Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.
Correct answer: B. 90,00,000
Detailed Explanation
Given:
- Compacted fill: e₁ = 0.7, V₁ = 8,50,000 m³
- Borrow pit soil (in situ): e₂ = 0.8, V₂ = ?
- Transportation cost: ₹10 per m³ (of borrow-pit soil actually excavated and hauled)
Key idea: compaction changes the void ratio but the volume of solid particles, Vs, is conserved — the same solid grains are simply repacked more densely. Since V = Vs(1+e):
Vs = V₁/(1+e₁) = V₂/(1+e₂)
V₂ = V₁ × (1+e₂)/(1+e₁) = 8,50,000 × 1.8/1.7 = 9,00,000 m³
Cost = 9,00,000 m³ × ₹10/m³ = ₹90,00,000 (90 lakh)
Key Concepts for Students
- Volume of solids is invariant under compaction: Vs = V/(1+e) stays constant even as the total volume and void ratio change.
- Looser soil needs more borrow-pit volume: since the borrow pit's void ratio (0.8) is higher (looser) than the compacted fill's (0.7), more in-situ volume must be excavated than the final compacted volume — compaction always shrinks total volume for the same solids.
- Always identify which volume the unit cost applies to — here it is the volume actually excavated/hauled from the borrow pit (V₂), not the final compacted volume.
- This calculation underlies real quantity-estimation work in earthwork and embankment projects, where borrow-pit volumes must be inflated to account for the looser in-situ state.