Geotechnical·MCQ explained

Which of the following factors does NOT affect permeability of soil?

Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.

Correct answer: D. Volume of soil

Detailed Explanation

Several genuine physical and structural factors influence a soil's permeability, but the overall bulk VOLUME of a soil sample — as opposed to its internal properties — is not one of them.

Why "Volume of soil" Is Correct

Permeability is governed by the internal structure and properties of the soil (particle size, void ratio, pore-fluid properties, etc.), not by the overall bulk volume of the sample being tested. A larger or smaller sample of the SAME soil, prepared and tested consistently, would show the same coefficient of permeability, since K is an intrinsic soil property, not one that scales with sample volume.

Why the Other Options Are Wrong

  • Properties of pore fluid: a genuine factor — viscosity and unit weight of the pore fluid (see Q11, Q28, Q35) directly affect permeability per the Kozeny-Carman relationship.
  • Void ratio: a genuine, major factor — permeability increases sharply with void ratio (more, larger, better-connected voids for water to move through).
  • Grain size of soil particles: a genuine, major factor — permeability varies enormously with particle size (see Q14's coarse sand to clay range), since particle size directly controls pore size and specific surface area.

Key Point

Permeability (K) is an INTRINSIC property of a soil — like density or specific gravity, it doesn't depend on how much of the soil you happen to be testing, only on its internal structure and composition.

Key Concepts for Students

  • This is a "which does NOT belong" style question — checking each option against a genuine mechanism (particle size → pore size; void ratio → void space; pore fluid properties → Kozeny-Carman relationship) quickly reveals volume as the odd one out.
  • See Q28 for a related question specifically confirming that both pore-fluid viscosity AND unit weight are genuine influencing factors.
  • See the Going Deeper section for the complete, consolidated list of every factor that DOES genuinely affect permeability across this whole topic.
  • Confusing an intrinsic property (like K) with an extrinsic one (like total volume or total discharge) is a common conceptual trap across many soil mechanics properties, not just permeability.

Going Deeper: The Complete List of Factors Affecting Permeability

Gathering every genuine permeability-influencing factor mentioned across this topic into one consolidated reference:

FactorHow It Affects Permeability
Particle size and shapeLarger, more rounded particles create larger, better-connected pores → higher K (see Q14, Q25, Q36)
Void ratio / porosityHigher void ratio means more space for flow → higher K (see Kozeny-Carman, Q11)
Degree of saturationHigher saturation means more of the void space is actually available for water flow → higher K (see Q11)
Properties of pore fluid (viscosity, unit weight)Higher viscosity → lower K; higher unit weight → higher K (see Q11, Q28, Q35)
Entrapped air / organic impuritiesBlock pore spaces, reducing effective flow area → lower K
Soil structure (flocculated vs. dispersed, layering)Affects how interconnected the pore network actually is, beyond just void ratio alone

Notice that every genuine factor on this list is an INTRINSIC characteristic of the soil-fluid system itself — none of them depend on how large a sample is being tested, which is exactly why bulk sample volume doesn't belong on this list.