Geotechnical·Solved numerical

A highly sensitive volcanic clay was investigated in the laboratory and found to have the following properties: (i) gwet = 12.50 kN/m3 (ii) G = 2.75 (iii) e = 9.0 (iv) w = 311% In rechecking the above values, one was found to be inconsistent with the rest. Find the inconsistent value and report it correctly.

By January 26, 20252 min read

A highly sensitive volcanic clay was investigated in the laboratory and found to have the following properties: (i) gwet = 12.50 kN/m3 (ii) G = 2.75 (iii) e = 9.0 (iv) w = 311% In rechecking the above values, one was found to be inconsistent with the rest. Find the inconsistent value and report it correctly

Problem Statement (Civil Services Exam 2001)

A highly sensitive volcanic clay has the following properties:

  • Wet unit weight (\( \gamma_{\text{wet}} \)) = 12.50 kN/m³
  • Specific gravity (\( G \)) = 2.75
  • Void ratio (\( e \)) = 9.0
  • Water content (\( w \)) = 311%

One of these values is inconsistent. Identify and correct it.

Solution

Assumption (i): \( \gamma_{\text{wet}} \) is inconsistent

\( S = \frac{wG}{e} = \frac{3.11 \times 2.75}{9.0} = 0.95 < 1 \) (Valid)
\( \gamma_{\text{wet}} = \frac{G + eS}{1 + e} \cdot \gamma_w = \frac{2.75 + 9.0 \times 0.95}{1 + 9.0} \times 9.81 \approx 11.09 \, \text{kN/m}^3 \)

Computed \( \gamma_{\text{wet}} = 11.09 \, \text{kN/m}^3 \) ≠ Given \( \gamma_{\text{wet}} = 12.50 \, \text{kN/m}^3 \). Hence, \( \gamma_{\text{wet}} \) is inconsistent.

Assumption (ii): \( G \) is inconsistent

\( \gamma_d = \frac{\gamma_{\text{wet}}}{1 + w} = \frac{12.56}{1 + 3.11} \approx 3.06 \, \text{kN/m}^3 \)
\( G = \frac{\gamma_d (1 + e)}{\gamma_w} = \frac{3.06 \times (1 + 9.0)}{9.81} \approx 3.115 \)
\( S = \frac{wG}{e} = \frac{3.11 \times 3.115}{9.0} \approx 1.076 > 1 \) (Invalid)

Since \( S > 1 \), this assumption is invalid. \( G \) is consistent.

Assumption (iii): \( e \) is inconsistent

\( \gamma_d = \frac{\gamma_{\text{wet}}}{1 + w} = \frac{12.53}{1 + 3.11} \approx 3.06 \, \text{kN/m}^3 \)
\( e = \frac{G \gamma_w}{\gamma_d} - 1 = \frac{2.75 \times 9.81}{3.06} - 1 \approx 7.828 \)
\( S = \frac{wG}{e} = \frac{3.11 \times 2.75}{7.828} \approx 1.093 > 1 \) (Invalid)

Since \( S > 1 \), this assumption is invalid. \( e \) is consistent.

Assumption (iv): \( w \) is inconsistent

\( \gamma_d = \frac{G \gamma_w}{1 + e} = \frac{2.75 \times 9.81}{1 + 9.0} \approx 2.698 \, \text{kN/m}^3 \)
\( w = \frac{\gamma_{\text{wet}}}{\gamma_d} - 1 = \frac{12.56}{2.698} - 1 \approx 3.655 \)
\( S = \frac{wG}{e} = \frac{3.655 \times 2.75}{9.0} \approx 1.117 > 1 \) (Invalid)

Since \( S > 1 \), this assumption is invalid. \( w \) is consistent.

Result:
  • Inconsistent value: \( \gamma_{\text{wet}} = 12.50 \, \text{kN/m}^3 \)
  • Corrected value: \( \gamma_{\text{wet}} = 11.09 \, \text{kN/m}^3 \)

Explanation

Key Steps:

  • Checked consistency of each parameter using phase relationships.
  • Ensured saturation (\( S \)) does not exceed 1 (100%).
  • Verified calculations using dry density and void ratio relationships.

Physical Meaning

1. High Void Ratio (\( e = 9.0 \)):

  • Indicates extremely porous structure typical of sensitive clays.
  • Results in low density and high compressibility.

2. Water Content (\( w = 311\% \)):

  • Reflects high water absorption capacity of volcanic clay.
  • Leads to significant volume changes upon drying or wetting.

3. Corrected Wet Unit Weight:

  • 11.09 kN/m³ aligns with high porosity and water content.
  • Ensures realistic saturation levels (\( S < 1 \)).

Engineering Significance:

  • Highlights importance of cross-verifying lab data.
  • Demonstrates sensitivity of volcanic clays to water content.
  • Reinforces need for accurate density measurements in geotechnical analysis.