Problem Statement
A 20 m chain was used for surveying. It was found to be exactly correct (20.00 m) before starting work. After chaining a distance recorded as 1400 m, the chain was checked and found to be 4 cm (0.04 m) too long. At the end of the day’s work, after chaining a total recorded distance of 2420 m, the chain was checked again and found to be 8 cm (0.08 m) too long. Find the true total distance measured.
Step-by-Step Solution
Key Information
- Nominal Length of Chain (L_nominal) = 20 m
- Initial Actual Length (L_start) = 20.00 m (Error = 0 cm)
- Actual Length after 1400 m (L_mid) = 20 m + 0.04 m = 20.04 m (Error = +4 cm)
- Actual Length after 2420 m (L_end) = 20 m + 0.08 m = 20.08 m (Error = +8 cm)
- Measured Distance Segment 1 = 1400 m
- Measured Distance Segment 2 = 2420 m – 1400 m = 1020 m
- Goal: Find the Total True Distance.
Step 1: Calculate True Distance for First Segment (0 m to 1400 m)
Measured Length (Segment 1) = 1400 m
Chain Length at Start of Segment 1 (L_start) = 20.00 m
Chain Length at End of Segment 1 (L_mid) = 20.04 m
Assume linear change in error. Use the average chain length for this segment:
Average Length (L_avg1) = (L_start + L_mid) / 2
L_avg1 = (20.00 m + 20.04 m) / 2
L_avg1 = 20.02 m
Apply the correction formula: True Distance = (L_avg / L_nominal) × Measured Distance
True Distance 1 = (20.02 m / 20 m) × 1400 m
True Distance 1 = 1.001 × 1400 m
True Distance 1 = 1401.40 m
Step 2: Calculate True Distance for Second Segment (1400 m to 2420 m)
Measured Length (Segment 2) = 2420 m – 1400 m = 1020 m
Chain Length at Start of Segment 2 (L_mid) = 20.04 m
Chain Length at End of Segment 2 (L_end) = 20.08 m
Calculate the average chain length for this segment:
Average Length (L_avg2) = (L_mid + L_end) / 2
L_avg2 = (20.04 m + 20.08 m) / 2
L_avg2 = 20.06 m
Apply the correction formula:
True Distance 2 = (L_avg2 / L_nominal) × Measured Distance 2
True Distance 2 = (20.06 m / 20 m) × 1020 m
True Distance 2 = 1.003 × 1020 m
True Distance 2 = 1023.06 m
Step 3: Calculate Total True Distance
The total true distance is the sum of the true distances of the two segments.
Total True Distance = True Distance 1 + True Distance 2
Total True Distance = 1401.40 m + 1023.06 m
Total True Distance = 2424.46 m
Final Result
Conceptual Explanation & Applications
Core Concepts:
- Systematic Error (Variable): Unlike the previous example where the chain error was constant, here the error changes during the measurement process (the chain stretches). This is also a systematic error, but its magnitude varies.
- Calibration Drift: The change in the instrument’s accuracy over time or due to use. In this case, the chain progressively became longer.
- Segmented Correction: When the error is known to vary, the measurement must be broken down into segments between points where the error was known or checked.
- Averaging Error Assumption: Within each segment, it’s common practice to assume the error changes linearly. Therefore, the average error (or average actual length) for the segment is used for correction. Average Length = (Length at Start + Length at End) / 2.
- Correction Formula Application: The standard formula (True = (L_actual_avg / L_nominal) * Measured) is applied individually to each segment.
Real-World Applications:
- Precise Surveying over Long Durations: Especially relevant when environmental factors (like temperature causing expansion/contraction) or instrument wear can cause calibration drift during the work. Intermediate checks are crucial.
- Using Older Equipment: Older tapes or chains might be prone to stretching or deforming with use, necessitating periodic checks and segmented corrections.
- Analysis of Historical Data: Interpreting old survey field notes where intermediate instrument checks might have been recorded.
- High-Accuracy Construction Layout: For large projects, ensuring that measurement errors due to instrument drift are accounted for throughout the process.
- Geodetic Control Surveys: Where very high precision is required, understanding and correcting for all sources of error, including instrument drift, is critical.
Why It Works:
Treating the entire 2420 m measurement with a single correction factor (e.g., based only on the final error of +8 cm) would be inaccurate because the chain wasn’t that long for the entire duration. Similarly, using only the initial state (correct length) is also wrong. By dividing the work into segments (0-1400 m and 1400-2420 m) based on when the chain’s length was known, we can isolate periods where the change in length was relatively small. Assuming a linear change in length *within* each segment allows us to estimate the *average* actual length of the chain during that specific measurement period (20.02 m for the first segment, 20.06 m for the second). Applying the standard correction formula to each segment using its corresponding average length provides a much better estimate of the true distance covered in that segment. Summing these individually corrected segment distances yields the most accurate overall true distance given the available information about the changing chain length.