Surveying·MCQ explained

Which of the following is a disadvantage of plane table survey?

Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.

Correct answer: B. It is essentially a tropical instrument.

Detailed Explanation: Disadvantages of Plane Table Surveying

Plane table surveying is a graphical field method where map plotting is done simultaneously with observation. To identify the correct answer, you must distinguish genuine disadvantages from advantages that have been reworded.

Why “essentially a tropical instrument” is a disadvantage:
The plane table uses a drawing sheet stretched across an open board, with plotting done in the open air. It cannot be used in wet, rainy, or windy weather because rain distorts and damages the paper and wind makes accurate sighting and drawing impossible. Dense forests also obstruct sighting. This makes it suitable only in dry, open, tropical or semi-arid climates — a significant limitation for surveys in temperate or wet regions.

Why the Other Options Are Advantages, Not Disadvantages

OptionCorrect classificationExplanation
A — Replaces compass in magnetic areasAdvantageA plane table uses geometric sighting rather than a magnetic needle. It is unaffected by local magnetic attraction, making it superior to a compass in areas with magnetic ore bodies or iron structures.
C — Suitable for small-scale mapsAdvantageThe plane table excels at rapid small-scale and medium-scale mapping because the map is built graphically in the field, reducing office work.
D — Simple and cheaper than theodoliteAdvantageThe equipment (table, alidade, drawing sheet) is simpler, lighter, and less expensive than a theodolite-and-total-station setup. This is an advantage, not a disadvantage.

Complete Disadvantages of Plane Table Survey (for revision)

#Disadvantage
1Essentially a tropical instrument — unsuitable in rain, strong wind, or cold humid conditions
2Heavy and cumbersome to transport (large board, tripod, accessories)
3Less accurate than theodolite or total station survey
4Paper distorts with changes in humidity and temperature, affecting plotted accuracy
5Requires skilled draughtsmen for accurate field plotting
6Cannot be used for accurate control surveys over large areas

Key Concepts for Students

  • Options A, C, D are advantages in disguise: This is a classic exam trap — three of the options describe genuine strengths of plane table surveying. Carefully read every option before selecting, and verify that the chosen option is a limitation, not a benefit.
  • “Tropical instrument” is the standard textbook phrasing: This exact phrase appears in all standard surveying textbooks (Bannister, Schofield, Punmia) as the primary disadvantage of plane table surveying. Memorise it as-is for objective questions.
  • Weather limitation is practical: In India and similar tropical countries, plane table surveying is widely used because of the predominantly dry weather. In the UK, Scandinavia, or monsoon seasons, the method becomes impractical, illustrating why the “tropical instrument” label is a genuine disadvantage in a global context.