A soil has a liquid limit of 40% and its plasticity index is 10%. The percentage passing through a 4.75 mm sieve is 60% and the percentage passing through a 75 micron sieve is 45%. The soil can be classified as:
Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.
Detailed Explanation
Full USCS classification of a soil sample follows a fixed decision sequence: first split the sample into coarse-grained vs. fine-grained by the 50% rule, then (for coarse-grained soil) compare gravel vs. sand fractions, then use the plasticity chart to pick the right secondary symbol.
Given: liquid limit WL = 40%, plasticity index IP = 10%, % passing 4.75 mm sieve = 60%, % passing 75-micron sieve = 45%.
Step 1 — Coarse or fine-grained? % passing 75 microns = 45%, so the coarse fraction is 100 − 45 = 55%. Since more than 50% is coarse, this is a coarse-grained soil.
Step 2 — Gravel or sand dominant? % passing 4.75 mm = 60%, meaning 40% is retained on 4.75 mm (the gravel fraction). The remainder between 4.75 mm and 75 microns is 60 − 45 = 15% (the sand fraction). Since gravel (40%) > sand (15%), the primary symbol is G (Gravel).
Step 3 — Silt or clay (secondary symbol)? A-line: (IP)A-line = 0.73(WL − 20) = 0.73(40 − 20) = 14.6%. The soil's actual IP (10%) is less than this A-line value (14.6%), so it plots below the A-line — classified as silt (M).
Why "GM" Is Correct
Combining the primary symbol (G, since gravel exceeds sand) with the secondary symbol (M, since the soil plots below the A-line as silt) gives GM — silty gravel.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
- SM: would require sand to exceed gravel — but here gravel (40%) clearly exceeds sand (15%), so the primary symbol must be G, not S.
- GC: would require the soil to plot above the A-line (clay behaviour) — but IP = 10% is below the A-line value of 14.6%, indicating silt (M), not clay (C).
- SC: combines both errors above — wrong primary symbol (should be G) and wrong secondary symbol (should be M).
Key Point
Full USCS classification is always a fixed sequence: (1) coarse vs. fine by the 50% rule, (2) gravel vs. sand by which fraction dominates, (3) A-line comparison for the secondary letter — skipping or reordering these steps is the most common source of classification errors.
Key Concepts for Students
- The 50% rule (Step 1) uses % passing 75 microns to decide fine- vs. coarse-grained — the complement of what you might expect at first glance.
- The gravel-vs-sand comparison (Step 2) uses the fractions between specific sieve sizes, not the raw passing percentages directly.
- The A-line comparison (Step 3) is identical in principle to Q11 and Q12's plasticity-chart questions, just applied here to decide a secondary letter instead of a full fine-grained symbol.
- This full three-step sequence recurs as the backbone of nearly every classification-from-lab-data question in this topic.
Going Deeper: The Full USCS Symbol System
The Unified Soil Classification System (USCS), developed by Arthur Casagrande (see Q20) and adapted in India as IS: 1498-1970 (see Q16), assigns every soil a two-letter symbol built from a primary letter and a secondary letter.
| Primary Symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
| G | Gravel |
| S | Sand |
| M | Silt |
| C | Clay |
| O | Organic soil |
| Pt | Peat / highly organic soil |
| Secondary Symbol | Meaning |
|---|---|
| W | Well graded (coarse-grained soils) |
| P | Poorly graded (coarse-grained soils) |
| M | Contains appreciable silt (used as e.g. SM) |
| C | Contains appreciable clay (used as e.g. SC) |
| L | Low compressibility / liquid limit < 50 (fine-grained soils) |
| H | High compressibility / liquid limit ≥ 50 (fine-grained soils) |
For coarse-grained soils (gravel/sand dominant), the secondary symbol is W or P (grading, from Cu/Cc — see Q1's Going Deeper) or M/C (fines content and character). For fine-grained soils (silt/clay dominant), the secondary symbol is L or H (compressibility, from the liquid limit — see Q11's Going Deeper), combined with the primary M/C/O distinction from the plasticity chart (see Q12's Going Deeper).
This is why the same underlying tools — sieve analysis percentages, the A-line, and the liquid limit — recur again and again throughout this topic: they are the complete input set the entire USCS symbol system is built from.