Select the option that is appropriate regarding the following two statements labelled Assertion and Reason Assertion: A loose, permeable, sandy soil has a higher infiltration capacity than that of a tight, clayey soil. Reason: A soil with poor under-drainage has a higher infiltration capacity.
Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.
Detailed Explanation
Infiltration capacity — the maximum rate at which soil can absorb water — depends heavily on soil type and drainage conditions, and this Assertion-Reason question tests both the direct comparison (sand vs. clay) and a claim about the effect of drainage quality.
Why "Assertion is true, but Reason is false" Is Correct
The Assertion is true: loose, permeable sandy soil, with its large interconnected pores, has a much higher infiltration capacity than tight, clayey soil. The Reason is false: it is actually GOOD under-drainage (not poor under-drainage) that gives a soil a higher infiltration capacity — poor drainage means water cannot move away from the surface layer fast enough, which reduces (not increases) how quickly more water can infiltrate.
Why the Other Options Are Wrong
- Both Assertion and Reason are false: incorrectly marks the Assertion as false — sandy soil genuinely does infiltrate faster than clayey soil, a well-established, correct fact.
- Both Assertion and Reason are true, but Reason is not the correct explanation of Assertion: incorrectly treats the Reason as true — poor under-drainage does not increase infiltration capacity; the Reason itself is factually wrong, not merely unrelated to the Assertion.
- Both Assertion and Reason are true and Reason is the correct explanation of Assertion: incorrect on the same grounds — the Reason's claim about poor drainage is false, so it cannot correctly explain a true Assertion.
Key Point
Good under-drainage supports HIGH infiltration capacity (by continuously making room for more water to enter from above); poor under-drainage causes water to back up and REDUCES infiltration capacity — the reverse of what this question's Reason claims.
Key Concepts for Students
- Infiltration capacity and permeability are closely related but distinct concepts — permeability describes flow through the soil generally, while infiltration capacity specifically describes water entering from the surface.
- See Q10 for the fuller list of factors affecting infiltration capacity, and a related subtlety (rainfall intensity affects the actual infiltration RATE, but not the soil's underlying capacity).
- Sand's large pore spaces allow rapid downward water movement; clay's small pores and high water retention slow infiltration considerably.
- This is the second Assertion-Reason question in this topic (see also Q4) — both reward checking each half of the statement independently rather than assuming a plausible-sounding pair must both be true.
Going Deeper: Infiltration Capacity: Concept and Controlling Factors
Infiltration capacity is the maximum rate at which a given soil, under given conditions, can absorb water at its surface — a ceiling on infiltration, not necessarily the actual observed rate at any given moment (which can be lower, depending on how much water is actually available, see Q10).
| Factor | Effect on Infiltration Capacity |
|---|---|
| Soil type (particle size, structure) | Coarser, more open structure increases capacity |
| Permeability of soil | Higher permeability generally supports higher infiltration capacity |
| Soil temperature | Affects water viscosity, and therefore ease of movement into and through the soil |
| Available (initial) soil moisture | Drier soil generally has higher initial infiltration capacity than already-wet soil |
| Under-drainage quality | Good drainage maintains capacity by continuously making room for more incoming water |
| Type of vegetation/crop cover | Root structures and surface cover can improve or impede infiltration |
Note what's NOT on this list: rainfall intensity itself. As covered in Q10, rainfall intensity determines how much of the soil's infiltration capacity is actually being used at any moment (the infiltration rate), but it does not change the underlying capacity of the soil itself.