Surveying·MCQ explained

The main advantage of the rise and fall method of booking levels over the height of instrument method is that it:

Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.

Correct answer: B. Provides a check on intermediate sights

Detailed Explanation: Rise and Fall Method Checks Intermediate Sights

Why B (Checks accuracy of intermediate sights) is correct: The main advantage of the Rise and Fall (R&F) method over the Height of Instrument (HI) method is that R&F arithmetically checks every staff reading, including intermediate sights (IS). The HI method does not check IS readings arithmetically.

Comparison: Rise and Fall vs. HI Method

FeatureRise and Fall MethodHI (Collimation) Method
ΣBS − ΣFS checkYes ✓Yes ✓
Checks Intermediate Sights (IS)YES — IS errors appear in rise/fall column and fail the ΣRise − ΣFall checkNO — IS errors do not affect any check; can go undetected
Field booking speedSlower (more columns)Faster (fewer columns)
Where preferredCross-sections, profiles with many IS readings where accuracy mattersRapid levelling where few IS readings are needed
Rise and Fall: 3 independent checks (1) ΣBS - ΣFS = Last RL - First RL (2) ΣRise - ΣFall = Last RL - First RL (3) ΣBS - ΣFS = ΣRise - ΣFall If an IS reading is wrong, checks (2) and (3) will FAIL, alerting the surveyor. HI method: only 1 check ΣBS - ΣFS = Last RL - First RL IS errors do NOT appear in this check.
  • Rise and Fall's key advantage: checks accuracy of intermediate sights (IS).
  • HI method cannot detect IS errors through its arithmetic check.
  • When IS accuracy matters (many IS readings), R&F is the preferred method.