Engineering Materials·MCQ explained

Which of the following tests is NOT used to test aggregate for its abrasion resistance in concrete works?

Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.

Correct answer: C. Soundness test

Detailed Explanation: Soundness Test Measures Weathering Resistance, NOT Abrasion

Why C (Soundness test) is correct (the answer to "which is NOT an abrasion test"): The soundness test assesses the resistance of aggregate to disintegration caused by weathering (freeze-thaw cycles, sulphate crystallisation). It has nothing to do with abrasion from mechanical wear. The other three tests — Los Angeles, Deval, and Dorry — all measure how much material is lost due to abrasive wear and impact.

Aggregate Abrasion Resistance Tests

TestStandardPrincipleAbrasion Test?
Los Angeles Abrasion TestIS 2386 Part 4Aggregate + steel balls rotated in drum for 500 revolutions; measure % loss by weight✓ YES — abrasion + impact
Deval Attrition TestIS 2386 Part 4Aggregate rotated in smooth drum (no balls) for 10,000 revolutions; measure % loss✓ YES — attrition/abrasion
Dorry Abrasion TestIS 2386 Part 4Aggregate pressed against rotating steel disc with sand abrasive; measure weight loss✓ YES — surface abrasion
Soundness TestIS 2386 Part 5Aggregate submerged in Na2SO4 or MgSO4 solution; crystallisation pressure mimics freeze-thaw; measure % loss✗ NO — weathering/disintegration test

Los Angeles Abrasion Test Details (Most Common)

AspectDetail
EquipmentRotating steel drum (diameter 711 mm, length 508 mm) with steel balls
SampleGraded aggregate (dependent on grading group A–G per IS 2386)
Revolutions500 (for coarse aggregate); 1000 (for fine aggregate)
ResultLos Angeles Abrasion Value (%) = (loss in weight / original weight) × 100
LimitsIS 456: max 30% for concrete wearing surfaces; 50% for ordinary concrete
  • Soundness test (IS 2386 Part 5) = weathering resistance test; NOT an abrasion test.
  • Abrasion tests: Los Angeles (most common), Deval attrition, Dorry abrasion — all measure mechanical wear.
  • Los Angeles value ≤30% required for concrete pavement wearing surfaces (IS 456).