Engineering Materials·MCQ explained

A concrete sample is cured at 15°C for 28 days. If the datum temperature is taken as −11°C, what is the maturity (°C·days) of the concrete sample?

Try it first: pick an option, then read the explanation.

Correct answer: D. 728

Detailed Explanation: Concrete Maturity Calculation

Why D (728 °C·days) is correct: The maturity method quantifies the combined effect of time and temperature on the strength development of concrete. The Nurse-Saul maturity formula uses a datum (reference) temperature (typically −10°C or −11°C), below which hydration effectively stops. Maturity M = ∑[Δt × (T − T0)], where Δt = time interval, T = curing temperature, T0 = datum temperature.

Step-by-Step Calculation

Nurse-Saul Maturity Formula: M = Σ [Δt × (T - T0)] Given: Curing duration (Δt) = 28 days Curing temperature (T) = 15°C Datum temperature (T0) = -11°C Calculation: M = 28 × (15 - (-11)) M = 28 × (15 + 11) M = 28 × 26 M = 728 °C·days

Maturity Method: Concept and Application

AspectDetail
PurposePredicts in-situ concrete strength without destructive cube testing; accounts for variable temperature curing conditions
Datum temperature (T0)−10°C or −11°C (Nurse-Saul); the temperature below which no strength gain is assumed to occur
Maturity units°C·days (or °C·hours if Δt in hours)
Maturity-strength relationshipPre-established curve (maturity vs. strength) calibrated for the specific concrete mix
Use caseCold weather concreting; formwork removal decisions; precast production scheduling; in-situ assessment

Why Other Options Are Wrong

OptionCalculation AttemptedError
A. 112Perhaps 28 × (15 − 11) = 28 × 4 = 112Treated datum as +11°C instead of −11°C; sign error
B. 308Perhaps 28 × (15 − 4) or similar miscalculationIncorrect temperature difference
C. 402Perhaps used 15 × 26 + 12 or other errorIncorrect combination of values
D. 72828 × (15 − (−11)) = 28 × 26 = 728Correct
  • Maturity M = ∑[Δt × (T − T0)] = 28 × (15 − (−11)) = 28 × 26 = 728 °C·days.
  • Key: datum temperature is −11°C; subtracting a negative number adds to the temperature difference.
  • The maturity method (ASTM C1074; ACI 228) allows early formwork removal and in-situ strength estimation without coring.